Reliability tests for qualitative research can be established by techniques like: refutational analysis, use of comprehensive data, constant testing and comparison of data, use of tables to record data, as well as the use of inclusive of deviant cases. Don't reveal incomplete or absurd reasons for doing the research. Don'ts. There are various elements and characteristics that define a clinical trial to be adequate and well-controlled per . Don't make too many generalizations. It's used a lot because it's effective at getting numbers. It is most commonly used to help inform new concepts, theories and products. A quality framework is lacking in qualitative research. (So if you have 5 segments, 5 is your multiplier for the total number you'll need.) Conjoint can help you get better results in all these ways: Launch better products; Design better packages; Set better prices In traditional qualitative, a good moderator does a lot verbally and nonverbally to put consumers at ease and help them open up--adopting their verbiage, adjusting wardrobe to fit the income mix of the recruit, etc. This type of data can be collected using diary accounts or in-depth interviews, and analyzed using grounded . Once you have determined your target audience, you can move forward with creating a screening guide. Typically, sample sizes will range from 5-20, per segment. Word Clouds is a type of data visualization technique which helps in visualizing one-word descriptions. To expand on the Don't #1 above, every aspect of running a focus group - from the facility you use, to the moderator, to the discussion guide, to the recruiting, incentives, and the report - is a far more complex process than internal marketing teams are equipped to handle. Reviewing the definitions set for each code at the beginning of the qualitative analysis process helped to re-ground me each day that I was working, and I was able to focus and code much quicker when trying to figure out how to label something. Do pass the squint test. Here are tips that should help. 3. Don't include anything that doesn't answer the questions. Conjoint analysis continues to be one of our most requested market research solutions and for good reason. Following this method allows the researcher to understand the user's thought process; thereby generating a lot of qualitative data. 2. We were honoured recently to be invited by (The ESOMAR Foundation) to be part of a series of webinars focussing on how qualitative research can support and inform non-profit organisations' aims and objectives, helping understand and address different types of donors.Sven Arn, Managing Director and Partner at Happy Thinking People, talked about how . The wording of questions will differ depending on . Citations that are old and outdated in the current context are to be avoided. First developed within the social sciences, qualitative research is now widely used to inform market research, by gaining unique consumer insight from a wealth of data. Focus on the uniqueness and novelty of your paper . REVEAL, Omniconvert's newest product . There are some mistakes researchers . Beyond the basic dos and don'ts, there are no tested dimensions we can use to compare one qualitative study from another. Dos and Don'ts Focus Group Discussion What is Focus Group Discussion (FGD)? Here's a few tips, with examples, for each: Qualitative. Because chances are you're going to think you found the love of your life. Rates are often more expensive the closer you get to your desired rental date. Focus groups are typically used to generate ideas, develop hypotheses, explore motivations and test reactions to concepts. You need to establish the background of your study in the Introduction section of your research paper such that it prompts the readers to read the rest of your paper. Various techniques can achieve results, depending on the subject of study. 3. . It is also used to explain the outcome of quantitative research methods. Jolee Graham, biostatistics director, Nicki Payne, director, IRT, and Katy Tam, director, biostatistics, discuss the components of successful randomization in research. Once you're a few documents in, do try to . Writing of problem statement should be for the audience and not for you. Questions that include multiple ideas or two questions in one will confuse respondents. This protocol can be used in two scenarios: as the user completes specified tasks or . Schuman, D. (1982). There are important "dos" in ethical research, many of which are outlined by the Council of American Survey Research Organizations (CASRO): DO respect the rights of all research participants: confidentiality, transparency, and privacy. Here are several data visualization techniques for presenting qualitative data for better comprehension of research data. Do: Do take time to build out and define your codebook. This means that qualitative researchers study things in their natural settings attempting to make sense of, or interpret, phenomenon in terms of the meanings people bring to them."-Denzin and Lincoln, 2003 It can be used to gather in-depth insights into a problem or generate new ideas for research. To identify and explore these mistakes, unstructured interviews were reflexively analyzed for emerging . Waiting until the last minute is risky. Though you may have a clear vision as to who your target audience may be, you may find that your screener results . Through active listening, surface level discussions rapidly give way to deeper motivations, and if the interviewer can demonstrate objectivity and candor, he or she can quickly establish a trusting relationship in the interview. The Do's and Don'ts. 6. In this video, you will learn about some DOs and DON'Ts. When people feel heard and understood, they are more likely to share. It is used to test or confirm theories and assumptions. The following are some sources of qualitative data: 1. Oxford: How To Content. Key Points: Focus on open-ended "how", "why" or sometimes "what" questions Qualitative research questions are beneficial for complex reasoning to get the right results. The tools might involve semi-structured or completely structured methods. Qualitative research involves collecting and analyzing non-numerical data (e.g., text, video, or audio) to understand concepts, opinions, or experiences. Deviations or inconsistency in following the defined inclusion and exclusion criteria make the findings unreliable. 7. Added bonus: when you reserve with plenty of time, you may be offered a pre-pay option that includes a discount. Online qualitative moderators are willing to humanize themselves, and even look silly to make respondents . These techniques can help support the data sourcing, data validation and data presentation . After an interview, Proeschold-Bell recommends immediately reviewing the data. A historical study is the ideal choice for studies that involve extensive . Do book early. Qualitative data is defined as non-numerical data, such as text, video, photographs or audio recordings. It is a form of qualitative research where questions are asked about their perceptions attitudes, beliefs, opinion or ideas. To bring this one home, let's answer the question we sought out to investigate: the sample size in qualitative research. This qualitative approach is particularly suited to examining human-related abilities, behaviors, and relationships-a complex and elusive issue for quantitative research (Aspers & Corte, 2019 . Here are some Dos and Don'ts to make the process a smooth one. Be creative! "interview don'ts" during her first attempt at qualitative interviewing as part of a study. Dos and Don'ts for Qualitative Writing 1. It is not uncommon for a researcher to employ more than one approach throughout their study. Qualitative research is a type of research that explores and provides deeper insights into real-world problems. Do use the full axis and maintain consistency. . 4. 1. Try to be concise and avoid discussions in the methodology chapters. Then they organize these ideas into a smaller number of broader themes. The tool kit for the data collection method of the research is quite flexible. First, they identify ideas that are repeated throughout the data. These mistakes occurred despite her attempts to learn qualitative interviewing best practices and develop her craft of interviewing beforehand. The role of participants is essential as it brings meaning to the study. General tips for good typing can help too. 5. It is also possible to use different types of research in the same study, an approach known as "mixed . The data gained can be organized and statistical analysis carried out. Focus group recruiting Do #2: Outsource the whole project. Social media provides a preponderance of data to researchers, and much of it will be spam. Do's of writing a qualitative research paper 1. Don't make excuses for poor writing. . TOP TIPS FOR QUALITATIVE RESEARCH 1. Often recorded as biography, life history or in the case of older/ancient . This will help you in preparing the introduction to the dissertation. (Jacob & Furegerson, 2012, p. 8) Here are some Do's and Don't's regarding nonverbal communication during interviews for qualitative research: Nonverbal Communication. In marketing research in particular, insight and understanding is the . Because it is such a powerful tool, "This helps capture good ideas that may otherwise be forgotten," she says. Yes, it . . They do this analysis in stages. Definition. Key Takeaways from Social Media Market Research. DO's: Examples of Open-Ended. Don't exceed the recommended word limits. To perform qualitative research, you must choose at least one research design approach that fits your topic. For very specific tasks, such as in user experience research, moderators will . It generally involves asking broader research questions, collecting more detailed data (e.g., interviews), and using nonstatistical analyses. Qualitative research, or "qual," involves collecting and analyzing non-numerical data to better understand how to improve customer experiences. Cite recent papers . 2. Do test your visualization against a color blindness simulator. DOs . DON'T's: Examples of Closed-Ended. 2. In qualitative research methods, interviews help you to get a deeper understanding of social trends as compared to the data collected using quantitative methods such as questionnaires. "Scientists aren't known for being good writers, so it's ok if my writing isn't good either." "This paper doesn't count for much anyway, so it's ok if it doesn't make sense.". Whether you're working with super hot co-eds, monkeys or economic data, trying to date the people, animals or things will just complicate your qualitative research. The problem statement should be clear and not ambiguous; The problem statement should be compelling and not unconvincing; It should be concise and not long winded. Avoid discussions of topic in methodology James, E. A., & Slater, T. (2014). Download a Free Qualitative Research Interview Checklist. Qualitative research is used to gain insights into people's feelings and thoughts, which may provide the basis for a future stand-alone qualitative study or may help researchers to map out survey instruments for use in a quantitative study. Valentin Radu is an entrepreneur, data-driven marketer, CRO expert, CVO evangelist, international speaker, father, husband, and pet guardian.He is the founder & CEO of Omniconvert, a SAAS company that provides growth solutions to mid-size eCommerce websites looking to become customer-centric. Research question should not be ambiguous as it will result in a haphazard start to the research study. Here are a few to watch for: Don't try to measure everything. By Edward Appleton, Happy Thinking People . Narrative inquiry records the experiences of an individual or small group, revealing the lived experience or particular perspective of that individual, usually primarily through interview which is then recorded and ordered into a chronological narrative. The main purpose of qualitative research is to recognize the social reality of the groups, cultures, and individuals. A Handy List of Don'ts. In qualitative research using grounded theory, researchers start with the data and develop a theory or an interpretation that is "grounded in" those data. . Ensure that questions are without bias. Don't lengthen your paper unnecessarily. Below we are going to discuss the do's and don'ts while executing data analysis. The solution of the problem stated should be fair and not biased. Someone you can't get enough of. In this paper, we understood the importance of an in-depth interview method of data collection. Do have your pie chart equal 100%. "Qualitative research involves an interpretive, naturalistic approach to the world. Hi Guys! Collect your data. Researchers focus on smaller user samplese.g., in interviewsto reveal data such as user attitudes, behaviors and hidden factors: insights which guide better designs. It explores the understanding of individuals within their social contexts. Do: Keep an open mind. The paper also explores the strength and limitations of an in-depth interview . Get your paper English edited and proofread . The form of data collection will depend on the research methodology. Consider how you will administer the questionnaire. In this way, qualitative research can be described as naturalistic research, looking at naturally-occurring social events within natural settings. In contrast, qualitative studies rely on personal accounts or documents that illustrate in detail how people think or respond within society. . The most common mistakes happen when people try to cut corners: Don't conduct only one group. Follow the Think Aloud Protocol. Here are five common design approaches: 1. Quantitative research. Action research problems play a critical role in . Highlight the originality of your paper . Avoid leading questions. (see Chapter 1 and FAQ.7) Decide on a research design (see Chapter 2) Keep a research diary to document your ideas and the research process Write Your Doctoral Dissertation or Thesis Faster: A Proven Map to Success. This type of analysis would be by the researcher without use of . Dissertation research question look different depending on whether they are qualitative or quantitative. Do's 1. 5. Thematic and descriptive analysis are being used for qualitative research. But correcting grammar is a very simple fix, and can go a long way to help clean up your writing. Policy analysis, education, and everyday life. It's premised on the idea that people know people similar to themselves. Each of the research methodologies has uses one or more techniques to collect empirical data, including interviews, participant observation, fieldwork, archival research, documentary materials, etc. The first step is to write a winning proposal to establish your research problem and decide on the research's approach and direction. Design questions that align with data collection and data analysis goals. Follow the generalized approach in your research paper . Qualitative research is the opposite of quantitative research, which . Here's tip #1 from our 10 Conjoint Do's and Don'ts: Do consider qualitative research at the outset. 1. One particular difference between qualitative and quantitative research is that the former requires . Ensure that all participants are voluntary, and that they have the right to . Ethical Dos and Don'ts. Don't quote your authors too much 2. And the Don'ts: Do not misrepresent yourself. Do keep it simple. Qualitative research is flexible and can be changed at any stage of the research work. Market research is an incredibly powerful way to gain insight into the thoughts, feelings, and opinions of your target consumers. Qualitative research is an important alternative to quantitative research in psychology. This type of research can be used to establish generalizable facts about a topic. These identify concepts and relationships that aren't easily observed through quantitative methods. Your readers should know why your research topic is important and how it will contribute to the development of knowledge in your field. Qualitative research is multimethod in focus, involving an interpretative, naturalistic approach to its subject matter. Make the questions as simple as possible. The following is a list of common do's and don'ts when completing research. Qualitative research is the methodology researchers use to gain deep contextual understandings of users via non-numerical means and direct observations. You can then save the file with your desired speed, and the quality can be a little better than the live speed changes in VLC. Do include legends and labels. People may think that questionnaire design is easy until they attempt to design one. Focus groups do take a certain amount of planning time, money and effort to conduct. Make yourself familiar with the complexities and requirements of action research before conducting the study. At the heart of market research studies is a questionnaire. Snowball sampling (or, chain referral sampling) is a method widely used in qualitative sociological research (Biernacki & Waldorf, 1981; Gray, 2004; Flick, 2009; Heckathorn, 2011). It is a single image composing multiple words associated with a particular text or subject. 1. A practical guide to qualitative research: A user-friendly manual in mastering research techniques and projects. 3. Qualitative research methods focus on the thoughts, feelings, reasons, motivations, and values of a participant, to understand why people act in the way they do. Questionnaire Dos and Dont's. Written by B2B International. Create interview questions that are clear and easy to understand. Tips. When you write a qualitative research paper, do not quote your authors too much 2. It feels as if this discussion is applying a quantitative mindset to qualitative research. Always by concise or avoid discussions in your methods chapters 3. Cancellation fees may apply . . By engaging in market research, you can stay ahead of market trends, reduce risk, and gather the data you need to gain buy-in for new projects or ventures. So, qualitative researchers would . Proeschold-Bell recommends numbering interviews chronologically to link interviews to the phase of development in which they were conducted. The purpose of the qualitative research interview is to study the experiences, views, or belief of an individual on a specific subject or topic. Instead of collecting numerical data points or intervene or introduce treatments just like in quantitative research, qualitative research helps generate hypotheses as well as further investigate and understand quantitative data. Effective interviewers (and facilitators) are friendly and open, and they know how to probe effectively. You need to avoid the discussion of the topic in the . Drag the slider to the left to slow down the speech (try 20% - 50%) without changing the 'pitch' so everyone doesn't end up sounding like Barry White. The Dos And Don'ts Of Problem Statement. Do ask for others opinions. (2006). Qualitative research methods include gathering and interpreting non-numerical data. With so many marketers using social media, there are sure to be some pitfalls, or "don'ts" along the way. DO: Start thinking about your research interests and possible focus early on Devise one or a few specific research questions that you would like to answer (see Chapter 1 and FAQ.3) Decide on a research strategyquantitative or qualitative? Defining your target audience is an essential step when conducting qualitative market research recruitment. Abstract and Figures. Qualitative research aims to provide an in-depth understanding of experiences, perspectives and histories. Interviews; Focus groups; Documents Types of qualitative research to explore social behavior or understand interactions within specific contexts include interviews, focus groups, observations and surveys. marketing Marketing Questionnaire Dos And Don'ts memo 1. (instead use their common or generic names) Avoid roman numerals (e.g., III, IX, etc.) . Qualitative research is mostly suitable for the type of explanatory research. A: Qualitative research is the "why" of customer research understanding not only what customers think but also why they think, feel, or act the way they do. The period generally has no place in a title (even a declarative phrase can work without a period) Likewise, any kind of dashes to separates title parts (however, hyphens to link words is fine) Chemical formula, like H 2 O, CH 4, etc. One of the main advantages of a focus . We discuss methods for conducting in-de The qualitative research interview . Make Time for Post-Interview Reflection. Don't lead the respondent into an answer. This type of research further uses interview methods and focus group for deep insights into the research questions. Common quantitative methods include experiments, observations recorded as numbers, and surveys with closed-ended questions. A focus group discussion involves gathering people from similar backgrounds or experiences together to discuss a specific topic of interest. Seidman, I. Revised on October 10, 2022. Qualitative research can be used to understand how an individual subjectively perceives and gives meaning to their social reality. Here are some of the do's and don'ts of writing a qualitative research paper. Qualitative Research. In this article we briefly review the more common qualitative interview methods and then focus on the widely used individual face-to-face in-depth interview, which seeks to foster learning about individual experiences and perspectives on a given set of issues. This means that qualitative researchers study things in their natural settings, attempting to make sense of, or interpret, phenomena in terms of the meanings people bring to them. For example, qualitative research may tell you that people in lower-income areas drop out of school and have lower literacy rates. Make the questions specific. Historical Study. What is Qualitative Research? As such, properly formed research questions are imperative to study success! Don't try to be perfect. . Do a thorough . Introduction. Quantitative research focuses on collecting numerical data that can be used to quantify the magnitude of a situation. The Do's and Don'ts of Randomization in Clinical Trials. Many researchers conceptualize quantitative and qualitative research as complementary and advocate combining them. Valentin Radu. Make research questions focused but flexible. If you want to run a focus group for your qualitative research, there is a lot to keep in mind about the process before you start and when you are in the roo. Lexington, MA:Heath. In this video I shared about the Do's and Don'ts in conducting Research or some Ethical Principles in Research.Hope this video helps you as you do y. Identify whether the question is suitable for this approach. DON'T Try to Date Your Subjects. Word Clouds. Interviewing as qualitative research: A guide for researchers in Education and Social sciences (3rd ed.) Quantitative research is expressed in numbers and graphs. Do plagiarism check . Think you found the love of your paper completely structured methods look silly to make respondents # 5 segments, 5 is your multiplier for the data gained can used Completely structured methods include interviews, and surveys money and effort to conduct &! ; mixed that your screener results focus group for deep insights into the is Clear and easy to understand ; mixed align with data collection will depend on the and. Exclusion criteria make the findings unreliable into the research study s newest product be fair and biased.: a guide for researchers in Education and social sciences ( 3rd ed qualitative research dos and don'ts color A Proven Map to Success the role of participants is essential as it brings meaning to the dissertation an! Or quantitative were reflexively analyzed for emerging their study writing of problem statement should be fair not You Determine sample Size in qualitative research methods anything that doesn & x27. Be one of our most requested market research studies is a single image composing multiple words with. Or avoid discussions in your methods chapters 3 you Determine sample Size in qualitative research may tell that These identify concepts and relationships that aren & # x27 ; t quote your authors too much. For researchers in Education and social sciences ( 3rd ed. ; premised!: 1 data: 1 requested market research solutions and for good reason more. The most common mistakes happen when people try to Date your Subjects define That the former requires your methods chapters 3 and analyzed using grounded defining your audience. Or generate new ideas for research following the defined inclusion and exclusion criteria make the unreliable. Ll need. to conduct easily observed through quantitative methods include gathering and interpreting non-numerical. Or generate new ideas for research identify whether the question is suitable for the total number you #! Numerals ( e.g., III, IX, etc. researchers, using Explore social behavior or understand interactions within specific contexts include interviews, focus groups do take a amount Moderators will the problem stated should be for the audience and not for you the. Https: //www.scribbr.com/methodology/qualitative-research/ '' > types of research in particular, insight and understanding is the ideal choice for that Is that the former requires within natural settings the current context are to be concise and avoid discussions in case! //Www.Researchgate.Net/Publication/319162160_In-Depth_Interview '' > What is qualitative research to explore social behavior or understand interactions within specific contexts include,. Good ideas that are clear and easy to understand research paper, we the., qualitative research - Marketing91 < /a > Definition into an answer So if you 5. Anything that doesn & # x27 ; s newest product throughout their study two scenarios: the Similar backgrounds or experiences together to discuss a specific topic of interest Determine sample Size in qualitative research Marketing91. Action research before conducting the study Thesis Faster: a guide for researchers in Education and sciences! Make the findings unreliable, life history or in the case of older/ancient be, you may have clear Discussion of the problem stated should be fair and not biased technique which helps visualizing Be used to gather in-depth insights into the research work > How do you Determine Size., which is qualitative research interview avoid the discussion of the problem stated should be fair and not you! Before conducting the study beliefs, opinion or ideas focus groups do take a certain amount of planning, Data collection and data presentation that may otherwise be forgotten, & amp ; Slater, (! Only one group in-de the qualitative research methods interview methods and focus group deep /A > avoid leading questions and avoid discussions in the same study an! Try to Date your Subjects at the heart of market research solutions and for reason. Stage of the research with a particular text or subject is used to gather in-depth insights into a number Choice for studies that involve extensive for example, qualitative research involves interpretive. Protocol can be changed at any stage of the research work analysis are being used for qualitative research to social! Difference between qualitative and quantitative research, which gained can be collected using diary accounts or interviews. Think that questionnaire design is easy until they attempt to design one option includes Throughout their study a few documents in, do not quote your too Methods chapters 3 respondent into an answer get enough of s effective at numbers! In one will confuse respondents include gathering and interpreting non-numerical data, such as user! If this discussion is applying a quantitative mindset to qualitative research as complementary and advocate combining.. And qualitative research dos and don'ts is the opposite of quantitative research methods include gathering and interpreting non-numerical data, such text! Data analysis goals pre-pay option that includes a discount, you may be offered a pre-pay option that a. Through quantitative methods include experiments, observations recorded as numbers, and analyzed using grounded a! Be avoided and descriptive analysis are being used for qualitative research - Marketing91 /a And surveys with Closed-Ended questions online qualitative moderators are willing to humanize themselves, and that have. Outcome of quantitative research methods areas drop out of school and have lower literacy rates also. - Marketing91 < /a > avoid leading questions organize these ideas into a smaller number broader! May otherwise be forgotten, & quot ; this helps capture good ideas that may otherwise be forgotten & As to who your target audience, you can move forward with creating a screening.! T. ( 2014 ) also explores the strength and limitations of an in-depth interview as Your target audience, you can & # x27 ; s newest product online qualitative moderators are to This discussion is applying a quantitative mindset to qualitative research as complementary and advocate combining them to qualitative Particular, insight and understanding is the visualization against a color blindness simulator analyzed using grounded, opinion ideas. Planning time, you may have a clear vision as to who your audience. Group discussion involves gathering people from similar backgrounds or experiences together to a Right to employ more than one approach throughout their study So if have. To researchers, and analyzed using grounded our most requested market research recruitment and can be used to or //Www.Scribbr.Com/Methodology/Qualitative-Research/ '' > types of interviews in qualitative research methods include gathering and interpreting data Or two questions in one will confuse respondents an answer the defined inclusion and exclusion criteria make the findings.. Discussion of the research questions, collecting more detailed data ( e.g., III, IX,.! Qualitative and quantitative research, which common mistakes happen when people try to measure everything, perspectives and. Practices and develop her craft of interviewing beforehand do try to measure everything mindset to qualitative research paper.! Expensive the closer you get to your desired rental Date people in lower-income areas drop out of school and lower! Whether they are qualitative or quantitative to who your target audience, you may that! Clinical trial to be one of our most requested market research solutions and for reason Screening guide they attempt to design one one of our most requested market research solutions for! Have a clear vision as to who your target audience, you can & # x27 ; s writing. Some sources of qualitative research may tell you that people in lower-income drop. Ix, etc. that involve extensive understood the importance of an in-depth interview method of data collection and presentation Research, which there are various elements and characteristics that define a clinical trial be. A preponderance of data to researchers, and that they have the right to segments Accounts or in-depth interviews, and much of it will be spam the paper explores Flexible and can be used in two scenarios: as the user completes specified tasks. The questions in the same study, an approach known as & quot ; mixed, qualitative involves Conduct only one group people try to cut corners: don & # x27 ; re a few tips with! Be used in two scenarios: as the user completes specified tasks or they are or! Individuals within their social contexts preparing the introduction to the research work conjoint analysis continues to avoided. People may think that questionnaire design is easy until they attempt to design.. Happen when people try to measure everything questions are asked about their perceptions attitudes, beliefs, opinion ideas. Etc. of market research solutions and for good reason a certain amount of time! Well-Controlled per strength and limitations of an in-depth understanding of experiences, perspectives and.! Paper unnecessarily context are to be avoided instead use their common or names! Diary accounts or in-depth interviews, focus groups, observations and surveys closer you get to your desired rental.. That includes a discount write your Doctoral dissertation or Thesis Faster: guide! Immediately reviewing the data gained can be described as naturalistic research, which that your screener.. Are voluntary, and that they have the right to defined inclusion and exclusion criteria make the findings unreliable and. Particular, insight and understanding is the identify concepts and relationships that aren & # x27 ; t lead respondent To avoid the discussion of the problem stated should be for the audience and not for you in user research. Inconsistency in following the defined qualitative research dos and don'ts and exclusion criteria make the findings unreliable in. Ideas that are old and outdated in the your Subjects is suitable the Protocol can be organized and statistical analysis carried out getting numbers that the former..
Vocabulary Apps For College Students, Https Discord Gg Mfhnfz4qe8, Wolt Rider Jobs Near Berlin, Convert Json To Jupyter Notebook, Azure Devops Burnup Chart, Veggie Straws Zesty Ranch Nutrition, Circle Keychain Mockup, Lucullus Bakery Cakes, Chocolate Ooey Gooey Butter Cake, Lilly Miller Bone Meal,